EDR V1.2 OAB Review, Comment 2: Group commmon requirements

[chris-little]

From @cnreediii The following requirements in the Class Queries

Requirement A.24: /req/queries/position
Requirement A.25: /req/edr/rc-area
Requirement A.26: /req/edr/rc-cube
Requirement A.27: /req/edr/rc-trajectory
Requirement A.28: /req/edr/rc-corridor
Requirement A.29: /req/queries/radius
Requirement A.31: /req/edr/rc-locations

Have a common set of SHALLs, MAYs, and SHOULDs. Could the common characteristics be specified in a single requirement instance and then additional requirements add specifics for each query type? This would really shorten that section.

[chris-little]

We will discuss this in the EDR API SWG, but I am minded to stay with the verbose but flat approach. We considered similar approaches in other parts of the spec, such as common shared attributes, and the hierarchical approach sometimes makes the text harder to understand.

[cnreediii]

@chris-little Thanks. Will abide by what the SWG decides :-)