You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The main idea: analyse decks same way as legality checks does -- so users can see commander brackets level of their deck. If it will works fine then such filter/requirements can be added to game table/tourney dialogs, so users can check/limit opponent's decks without deck discloses (current users can limit decks by edh levels/points but it's a hidden and non-intuitive feature).
Brackets system must be implemented same as edh power levels -- each deck must be analysed to search and calc cards with specific abilities/effects. Old edh implementation uses text search only (see AbstractCommander->getEdhPowerLevel). But new implementation can use abilities search, not text only.
It's not fully automated feature, but can find out 95% of all use cases. Moxfield has useful tools to find out and check cards/decks for specific bracket level: https://moxfield.com/commanderbrackets
Features to implement:
code: add deck analyse feature to find commander bracket level;
tests: add some example decks from each level to make sure xmage's bracket system can find correct level;
gui: add bracket level info in deck editor (as part of legality check - as 5 level buttons, so users can select cards from 4 level as example);
gui: add max bracket limit to new table/tourney dialog (can be added to custom options, default is 5);
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I would suggest that this should likely replace the Power Level system, especially given the power level's undocumented functionality for banning a color from your table.
The brackets do not seem to be designed with particular algorithmic support in mind - "no intentional early 2-card infinites" for example in Bracket 3 - but https://commanderspellbook.com/ has a database of 39,887 combos and we could see if we can get a listing of 2-card infinite combos from them to ban those from brackets 1 and 2, then there may be some judgment calls necessary on "is this a 2-card infinite that we should ban from bracket 3 because it's Too Easy To Do?"
Some days ago wizards presented commander brackets system (reddit summary) to rank player's decks.
The main idea: analyse decks same way as legality checks does -- so users can see commander brackets level of their deck. If it will works fine then such filter/requirements can be added to game table/tourney dialogs, so users can check/limit opponent's decks without deck discloses (current users can limit decks by edh levels/points but it's a hidden and non-intuitive feature).
Brackets system must be implemented same as edh power levels -- each deck must be analysed to search and calc cards with specific abilities/effects. Old edh implementation uses text search only (see AbstractCommander->getEdhPowerLevel). But new implementation can use abilities search, not text only.
It's not fully automated feature, but can find out 95% of all use cases. Moxfield has useful tools to find out and check cards/decks for specific bracket level: https://moxfield.com/commanderbrackets
Features to implement:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: