Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

X website isn't blocked, even though it's on my blocklist #680

Open
cstigler opened this issue May 17, 2021 · 24 comments
Open

X website isn't blocked, even though it's on my blocklist #680

cstigler opened this issue May 17, 2021 · 24 comments
Labels

Comments

@cstigler
Copy link
Member

cstigler commented May 17, 2021

This is a meta-issue to contain all of the cases where a specific website or service isn't blocked, but it should be (it's on your blocklist and a block is running). Please add all such problems as comments on this issue, instead of creating new bug reports for each website.

Debugging Steps Before Adding a Site To This List

  1. Make sure you're on the latest version of SelfControl
  2. Make sure the block is actually running (you open SelfControl and it shows a timer)
  3. Make sure the requested site is actually on your blocklist and spelled correctly (click "View Blocklist" to make sure it's there)
  4. Make sure you're not using a VPN or proxy - they are not compatible with SelfControl
  5. Clear your browser cache, then restart your browser
  6. If the site still isn't accessible, add it to this list

Summary (i.e. your situation)

Blocks generally work for me (websites are blocked properly), but this one specific website or service is still accessible. I'm on the latest version of SelfControl, double-checked that the site is on my blocklist, am not using a VPN/proxy, and have already tried clearing my browser cache. I've run multiple blocks and this behavior is consistent.

How To Add a Site

  1. Search this page (Cmd-F) to see if the website is already on this list. If so, react to that comment with a thumbs-up, instead of adding a new comment.

  2. If not, add a comment on this issue in the following format:

    Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list):

    Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? (Yes/No)

    Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block?

    If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist?

    How long have you noticed this issue?

    Any other notes, ideas, or comments?

@cstigler cstigler added the bug label May 17, 2021
@cstigler cstigler pinned this issue May 17, 2021
This was referenced May 17, 2021
@cstigler
Copy link
Member Author

Reporting on behalf of @harveycabaguio @colasbd @gandalfsaxe @Armingus from #409 :

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): telegram.org / web.telegram.org

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Unclear

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? n/a

How long have you noticed this issue? since late 2016

Any other notes, ideas, or comments?

@Pari-bola
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): telegram.org / web.telegram.org on Safari

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? n/a

How long have you noticed this issue? since 23rd May

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? Probably a Safari setting since it does block on Chrome. Curiously, it also blocks web.whatsapp.com on both Chrome and Safari but not web.telegram.org on Safari.

@quantuminformation
Copy link

I find that https://gats.io is blocked on FF but not on safari

@internetuser21
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): lipstickalley.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? Not using.

How long have you noticed this issue? I first had this issue when I upgraded my Mac Catalina to Big Sur about a month ago. I was able to eventually get it to start working by uninstalling and reinstalling the App and restarting my computer. It then took like 10 minutes for it to actually start working. Yesterday I had to restart my computer and noticed that the block wasn't working correctly yet again. I tried doing what I did last time and the issue hasn't been fixed. It's been hours.

@jordan339
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): popjustice.com AND forum.popjustice.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? N/A

How long have you noticed this issue? Since downloading and using SelfControl over a year ago. The issue with this website is not intermittent. I have never been able to block this website while always being able to successfully block all others.

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? N/A

@Kscoop
Copy link

Kscoop commented Dec 10, 2021

PLEASE HELP. I lost password for self-control app. Now it won't work at all. I desperately need it to stop my Internet addiction. PLEASE HELP. Email me with solution at [email protected]

@makerboiAdi
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): twitter.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? (Yes/No) Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? No

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? NA

How long have you noticed this issue? Weeks / Months

Any other notes, ideas, or comments?
It works sometimes. If I follow all the instructions (restarting self control, resetting browser cache, restarting laptop etc), then Twitter does get blocked. However, the next block seems to be ineffective. In all it seems a bit inconsistent and that I would need to repeatedly follow the instructions / restart things to get it working (all other sites remain blocked)

@everythingwillbetakenaway

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): eksisozluk.com / https://www.gazeteduvar.com.tr / https://www.birgun.net

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? (Yes/No) Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? NA

How long have you noticed this issue? Weeks

Any other notes, ideas, or comments?
It blocks it on Google Chrome but not Safari. It was blocking when timer started but right now it is not blocking.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented May 1, 2022

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list):
Website:
– dexerto.com
– hltv.org

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site?
Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block?
Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist?
No, am not using an allowlist.

How long have you noticed this issue?
I just started using SelfControlApp today, and I noticed it immediately that it isn't blocking the website.

Any other notes, ideas, or comments?
It blocks on Chrome but not Safari.
Before I had SelfControlApp, I had the same issue when using nano /etc/hosts.
It would block all the websites except for the two sites above, the blocking works on Chrome when I used nano /etc/hosts , and not on Safari.

@Krisperr
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): youtube.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes.

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist.

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist?

How long have you noticed this issue? Since downloading app, 1 hour.

@ahydrophyte
Copy link

ahydrophyte commented Dec 11, 2022

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list):
https://poki.cn
https://poki.com
https://www.crazygames.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? (Yes/No)
Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block?
blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist?

How long have you noticed this issue?
1 day

Any other notes, ideas, or comments?

@tjmahier
Copy link

colonist.io
https://colonist.io

Yes
blocklist

@Fossil-F
Copy link

myanimelist.net
beginningafterend.com
aquamanga.com
mrcomics.com
mangarock.com
mangabuddy.com
1stkissmanga.io
reality-quest.online
nitroscans.com
luminousscans.com
mm-scans.org
lightnovelworld.com
darkscans.com
novelcool.com
readwn.com
allfreenovel.com
allnovel.net
novelbin.net
wuxiaworld.com
mangasushi.net
mangasushi.org
zeroscans.com
flamescans.org
reaperscans.fr
reaperscans.id
reaperscans.com
asura.gg
asurascans.com

I've followed all debugging procedures.
I am using a blocklist.

I just noticed it today, I've had these on the list in a while, but I haven't opened any of them in a while, it's just when I revisited one did it reopen, and I found it odd, so I searched the web and read other issues, and noticed that people were having this issue and it was reported on GitHub, so I thought I would check other sites, and I had this list of sites that SelfControl didn't block.

@cstigler cstigler mentioned this issue Mar 1, 2023
Closed
@parkwaycraw
Copy link

parkwaycraw commented Jun 9, 2023

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list):

  • scrolller.com
  • mage.space
  • patreon.com
  • github.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? YES
Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? BLOCKLIST ONLY
How long have you noticed this issue? SINCE 2 MONTHS AGO

@vintageplayer
Copy link

Hey,
I'm facing a different problem. Sites that are not on the blocklist are being blocked. I'm not entirely sure why, but
For eg these two sites don't load, even though they're not the blocklist:

I'm curious what's happening.

@abhinavkari
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): https://store.epicgames.com/

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist?

How long have you noticed this issue? 1 day

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? No

@AysunYilmaz90
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list) www.webcammeiden.nl on Safari, Chrome

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

If you're using an allowlist, what other websites are on your allowlist? n/a

How long have you noticed this issue? since 1st of May

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented Aug 21, 2024

Site / Host Name www.skipthegames.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

How long have you noticed this issue? over the past two years

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? Seems self control blocks everything else. I've also tried adding it with different addresses from www to http etc etc. Nothing works . I do not have a VPN or Proxy running

@bwabwacelery
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): politico.com, www.politico.com, www.politico.eu

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

How long have you noticed this issue? A week (when I began using the app)

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? This problem is arising in Safari, but not in Firefox

@bwabwacelery
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): substack.com, reader.substack.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Yes

Are you using a blocklist or allowlist (fka whitelist) block? Blocklist

How long have you noticed this issue? A week (when I began using the app)

Any other notes, ideas, or comments? As with Politico, this site is not blocked in Safari, though it is successfully blocked in Firefox

@bwabwacelery
Copy link

Over the past few weeks, SelfControl has often been blocking only roughly half the sites on my Blacklist. Some sites are still reliably blocked (e.g. Wikipedia) while others come and go. Restarting, clearing cache, and so forth does not always fix the problem but sometimes appears to. The problem started around the time I upgraded to Sequoia 15.1 though I am not 100% certain that the timing was exact.

@RexSaini
Copy link

anime-planet.com
it is blocking it on brave and chrome but not one safari

@centuryboy774
Copy link

anime-planet.com it is blocking it on brave and chrome but not one safari

Same here, On the Zen browser which is based on Firefox it works perfectly fine. Issue being I don't use Zen every day I use Safari. Self Control doesn't block the website on my black list on Safari for whatever reason and I cannot find out why.

@3fishgenie
Copy link

Site / Host Name (exactly as added to your list): www.artstation.com

Have you followed all of the above debugging steps before adding this site? Everything except resetting cache.

How long have you noticed this issue?
Since Dec 15

All my other blocks work and I am on the newest version

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests